If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, WWD may receive an affiliate commission.
Popping the question isn’t as simple as ducking into your local jeweler and making a purchase: Aside from figuring out what setting and stone shape your partner prefers, finding a gem that aligns with their style, feels heirloom-worthy, and falls within your budget is a tall ask. While there are many e-tailers out there, finding one that seamlessly guides you through the process is, well, like finding a diamond in the rough. Blue Nile, founded in 1999, has recognized many of these hurdles aspiring fiancées face, eliminating the guesswork that goes into creating a Blue Nile engagement ring that’ll have her say, “yes!”
With ethically sourced, high-quality diamonds, Blue Nile not only ensures the stones you purchase are gorgeous, as they undergo a rigorous certification process (more on that later!) but that you’re purchasing diamonds guilt-free. As one of the leading engagement ring jewelers, Blue Nile prioritizes craftsmanship and the use of quality materials, so you know when customizing your diamond ring, it’s made to be worn and cherished for years to come.
Starting off by selecting a setting and band on their website, Blue Nile walks you through each step of designing your engagement ring online, letting you pick the carat size via filter (or with some help from a Blue Nile customer service representative). Whatever your needs are, Blue Nile ensures that the diamond you select hits the four Cs (clarity, cut, color, and carat weight) you’re hoping for, with its extensive range of stones, from dainty vintage-inspired stones to light-catching emeralds and masterfully cut marquise diamonds. Blue Nile also offers both lab-grown and ethically sourced diamonds, so no matter your preference, something will be available for you as you shop.
Another big benefit of shopping Blue Nile’s engagement rings: The company is transparent about pricing throughout the process, ensuring you won’t be scratching your head as everything is totaled up. While the price points below reflect the setting and the specific metal you’re after, you’ll get a full download as you continue to move to pick out the carat you think will work best for you and your fiancé.
Unsure of where to start? Consider some of the most popular styles in 2024, like east-west settings, mixed metals, as well as grey diamonds that feel hauntingly vintage and colorful gems that deliver a bespoke stack. We’ve also seen TikTok trends influence engagement ring preferences, from rings that evoke quiet luxury to large, flashy rings that feel like they’d be right at home on the hand of Carmela Soprano. From multi-stone rings á la Ariana Grande to the newer trend of a three-stone ring that many brides have been opting for, there’s something for everyone on Blue Nile. If something timeless is more your vibe, then you also can’t go wrong with the brand’s classic styles, like a stunning solitaire engagement ring.
We’ve scoured Blue Nile to find the best of the best for you. From a classic solitaire to toi et moi styles we’ve seen explode recently, we’ve rounded up Blue Nile’s best engagement rings of 2024.
Blue Nile Classic Four Prong Solitaire Engagement Ring In 18k Yellow Gold
Material: 18K Yellow Gold
Setting Type: Prong
Width: 2.00mm
One of the more versatile options on the market, the classic four-prong solitaire accommodates seven stone options, from heart to princess to emerald cut diamonds. Best for the bride-to-be whose style changes consistently, this setting is ideal for a fiancé who’s unsure of what to get. The simple band and four prongs allows the diamond to shine on its own.
What testers say: “I love this ring and my fiancé does too! I compared the prices to other online retailers and the closest I found in price was [way more] than I paid at Blue Nile. I had to get this ring resized and Blue Nile’s customer service was outstanding. Free shipping both ways. No worries and very happy buyer.”
Price upon publish date of this article: $660
Blue Nile Heirloom Petite Milgrain Engagement Ring In 14k White Gold
Material: 14K White Gold
Setting Type: Pavé
Width: 3.00mm
If you’re looking for a ring setting at an affordable price point that feels like an heirloom, look no further. A slim band makes this Blue Nile engagement ring perfect for stacking, and the setting elevates the center diamond to maximize the look of the gem, no matter the carat weight.
What testers say: “The ring was just as expected and my fiancé thinks it’s just perfect. The online preview with the diamond I chose was an accurate representation of the final product. Additionally, being able to visually compare diamonds was a huge factor in choosing the final product.”
Price upon publish date of this article: $540
Blue Nile Three-Stone Trapezoid Sidestone Diamond Engagement Ring In Platinum
Material: Platinum
Setting Type: Prong
Width: 2.00mm
Classically elegant, this setting is compatible with both emerald and ascher diamonds, which are both feel timeless and sophisticated. Able to accommodate up to 8 carat diamonds, this setting visually enlarges the center diamond with the smaller two on each side. It’s the perfect mix of quiet luxury and heirloom-inspired.
Price upon publish date of this article: $7,560
Blue Nile Scalloped Pavé Diamond Engagement Ring In 18k White Gold
Material: 18K White Gold
Setting Type: Pave
Width: 2.40mm
For the bride-to-be who wants a more dramatic, high-shine ring, Blue Nile’s Scalloped Pavé diamond ring is the one for her. It’s perfect for a bride who intended to keep her wedding band as simple as possible and lets her engagement ring catch the light. It’s also great for grooms looking to keep the center stone smaller — the pavé gems visually support the main stone for a wow-worthy reaction.
What testers say: “Exceptional service and product quality of the highest order. My fiancé absolutely loves her new ring. It was everything we imagined it would be and then some. I will definitely recommend Blue Nile to others, including my family, loved ones and friends.”
Price upon publish date of this article: $1,890
Blue Nile Classic Pear Shaped Sapphire Engagement Ring In Platinum
Material: Platinum
Setting Type: Prong
Width: 2.15mm
With two medium pear-shaped sapphires framing a beautiful diamond (anything from round to heart-shaped), this Blue Nile engagement ring evokes an inversion of the sapphire and diamond pairing that Princess Diana made popular in the ’90s. It feels equally retro and modern, and perfect for a girl who prefers cool tones and colors.
What testers say: “My fiancé absolutely adores this ring. She receives many compliments which makes me happy to see her in a such a good mood all the time. The diamond quality was also excellent and the sparkle of the gem is beautiful. The ring was also delivered very promptly and in time for my proposal. Over all I’m very happy with my purchase.”
Price upon publish date of this article: $1,580
Blue Nile Two Stone Engagement Ring With Pear Shaped Diamond In 14k White Gold
Material: 14K White Gold
Setting Type: Prong
Width: 2.00mm
This toi et moi engagement ring style is having a moment, with these two-stone engagement rings seen on the fingers of celebrities like Megan Fox. We love that the larger stone can be set in a variety of shapes.
Price upon publish date of this article: $4,730
Blue Nile The Gallery Collection Floating Diamond Engagement Ring In Platinum
Material: Platinum
Setting Type: Prong
Width: 1.9mm
Floating diamond rings are spring 2024’s hottest engagement ring trend — the unique setting is a beautiful way to showcase a stunning diamond. While at first glance the ring looks simple, the intricate and complex craftsmanship that goes into creating a floating engagement ring is sure to get lots of compliments.
What testers say: “I built a custom engagement ring for my fiancée, meticulously going through diamonds under 10x magnification to find the perfect center stone! I liked how [Blue Nile] helped guide me through the process, even suggesting similar diamonds as upgrade/downgrade options. I was very pleased with the rendering but my oh my… seeing it in person is breath taking. A truly wonderfully crafted work of art, I would absolutely recommend Blue Nile to anyone!”
Price upon publish date of this article: $3,150
Blue Nile Bella Vaughan Trapezoid Three Stone Engagement Ring In 18k Yellow Gold
Material: 18K Yellow Gold
Setting Type: Prong
Width: 2.10mm
A twist on a classic three-stone setting, Blue Nile enlisted renowned jeweler Bella Vaughan to design this three-stone engagement ring. Visually, the three stones look like one, making it eye-catching and luxurious. It’s a classic with a twist, sure to get attention and compliments as it catches the light.
Price upon publish date of this article: $7,040
The Benefits of Buying an Engagement Ring With Blue Nile
No two online jewelers are alike, and Blue Nile prides itself on offering special services unlike any other retailer. With services such as price matching, complementary ring resizing and cleaning, and a team of customer service representatives who ensure leading up to the proposal, that saying “I do” is a breeze, you’ll feel well taken care every step of the way. Whether you hope to customize your ring or want to ensure a smooth delivery, Blue Nile is one of the best online jewelers for engagement ring shopping.
- Price matching: Blue Nile believes they sell the best pieces at the best prices on the market — no markup for a name-brand ring here. In most cases, Blue Nile expects to have the lowest price, but can often match the price if the competitor’s estimate happens to be lower than Blue Nile’s.
- GIA certifications for every diamond: As part of the price-matching program, the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) will grade your diamond. Note this only applies to loose diamonds, not set diamonds.
- Free appraisals with purchases over $1,000: An appraisal is a document that will state the retail replacement value of your ring. In the incident of loss, theft, or damage, the document will help you file an insurance claim, ensuring you’ll be able to replace your ring without worry or at a major financial loss.
- Complimentary resizing, cleaning, and servicing: Sometimes, especially if you’re browsing independently, you’ll need a resize. Blue Nile makes it easy and free, ensuring no matter what happens, resizing and cleaning are available to you and your spouse. It’s important to clean your engagement ring every two weeks at home, especially if you want to ensure the longevity of your ring. From daily wear, debris, oil, and cosmetic residue can accumulate on the surface of the metal and stone, making cleaning a necessity.
- Special order and custom options: Finding a ring as special as your beloved can sometimes be a challenge, but Blue Nile makes special orders and customization a breeze, with customer service available to help guide you through the process.
- Financing options: Blue Nile is committed to making sure the ring you purchase is one you’re happy with, without cutting corners. Whatever your budget may be, Blue Nile has a variety of options to help you finance your dreams. You can check on Blue Nile’s website without impact to your credit score to see if you pre-qualify for their financing program.
How We Selected the Best Blue Nile Engagement Rings
Since 1910, WWD — often referred to as “the fashion bible” — has been the leading industry voice of authority for senior executives in the global women’s and men’s fashion, retail and beauty communities, while also informing the consumer media that cover the market. Today, WWD’s breaking news and trend coverage continues to be a trustworthy resource for both fashion insiders and consumers alike. Our shopping editors continue to uphold WWD’s editorial standards and values with quality, expert-backed product selections.
To create this list of the best Blue Nile engagement rings, our editors researched jewelry trends, looked into various metals, and evaluated the key factors to seek out in a precious stone. Using this information, we reviewed Blue Nile’s extensive offering of engagement rings, selecting top-rated settings that provide options for various budgets and aesthetics. As part of this process, we also researched perks that Blue Nile offers to its customers, comparing these against options from other online jewelers to highlight the exclusive benefits shoppers can expect from shopping for engagement rings with Blue Nile. Learn more about us here.
Meet the Author
Fernando Snellings is a contributing beauty and fashion writer for WWD. An alumni of the School of Visual Arts, Snellings has worked in various roles in the fashion industry for several years. As a freelance writer, he actively keeps his finger on the pulse on the latest fashion and beauty trends, including wedding and engagement ring trends, like those from Blue Nile.
